First, a big thank you to my high school English teacher for introducing this recipe to me. I made tiramisu as a part of a demonstration in her Speech class in high school…yes, I know, I always was a bit odd.
I must tell my Ladyfingers story from yesterday…
I planned to make tiramisu for a small party we hosted last night. I had all of the ingredients, minus the Ladyfingers. I was planning on picking those from the market a few blocks from our house. I bundled my 7 month old daughter to face the 27 degree morning, set out for the post office, dry cleaners and market and arrived at the bakery to be told (by the very disinterested purveyor of the bakery) that they were OUT of LADYFINGERS. I was dismayed. Immediately, I walked over to dear Tess at Bower’s cheese shop and lamented. She offered up slices of different cheeses and I began to feel hopeful again, especially when I tasted this cheese. My daughter also tasted some of her first cheese much to her delight. But wait, the ladyfingers…so, I stopped by this grocer. I have a love/hate relationship with this establishment. That’s another story… I asked the lady at the counter if they sell ladyfingers.
With a disgusted look on her face, she exclaims, “LADYFINGERS? NO! We do not carry ladyfingers. They are very high in sugar and trans fats.”
Seriously?! So not only was the bakery out and time was running of the essence for the espresso mixture to soak into the cakes, but the nerve of this lady to rain on my parade reminding me that tiramisu is not “organic” or healthy. I bit my tongue and marched out of the store thinking, “YOU would be a much more pleasant woman if you had a good dose of sugar and trans fats.”
I managed to drive to the grocery store quickly and BEG their bakery department manager to search the back room for the desperately needed ladyfingers. When she emerged with three packages, I loudly exclaimed, “You have made my day!” I shared with her the nasty trans fats encounter from earlier, and I reminded her of the joy she brings to so many people in our city.
So, without further drama, I offer you one of my favorite desserts…
16 oz container mascarpone cheese
½ tsp salt
½ C plus 2 tbsp powdered sugar
3 tbsp plus 1/3 C coffee-flavor liqueur (Kahula)
1 ½ tsp vanilla extract
3 1-oz squares semi-sweet chocolate, grated
1 ½ C heavy or whipping cream
2 tsp instant espresso-coffee powder
2 3-4 ½ oz packages ladyfingers
1. In a large bowl, with a wire whisk or fork, beat mascarpone, salt, ½ C sugar, 3 tbsp liqueur, 1 tsp vanilla, and 2/3s of grated chocolate.
2. In a small bowl, beat 1 C heavy cream until stiff peaks form. With rubber spatula or wire whisk, fold whipped cream into cheese mixture.
3. In small bowl, stir instant espresso powder, remaining 1/3 C liqueur, remaining ½ tsp vanilla, and 2 tbsp water.
4. Separate ladyfingers into halves. Line glass or crystal bowl with one-fourth of ladyfingers, brush with 2 tbsp of espresso mixture. Spoon 1/3 cheese mixture over ladyfingers. Repeat with ladyfingers, espresso mixture, and cheese mixture to make at least 2 more layers. Top with remaining ladyfingers, gently pressing ladyfingers into cheese mixture. Brush ladyfingers with remaining espresso mixture. Sprinkle remaining grated chocolate over top of dessert, reserving 1 tbsp. for garnish.
5. In a small bowl, with mixer at medium speed, beat remaining ½ C cream and remaining 2 tbsp powdered sugar until stiff peaks form.
6. Spoon whipped cream into decorating bag with large star tube. Pipe large rosettes on top of the dessert (OPTIONAL.)
7. Sprinkle reserved grated chocolate on whipped-cream rosettes.
Refrigerate until chilled and to blend flavors. (I think at least 6 hours–making this a certified “make-ahead dessert.”)
note: The phrase tirami su literally means “pick me up” or “pull me up” in reference to the effects of the sugar and espresso.
It is also thought to mean “pick me up to heaven” due to the delightful taste.